Author Topic: Noob wants to load 1k Silhouette MG 124gr JHP  (Read 2325 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline joejoe05

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 31
Noob wants to load 1k Silhouette MG 124gr JHP
« on: April 11, 2020, 01:15:45 AM »
I live in northern California and I'm stuck at home for at least another 3 weeks due to the shelter in place. I've been wanting to try reloading for a while and finally took the jump. I got a Dillon XL750 delivered this week and bought the following based on my research on forums:

Bullets: Montana Gold 124gr JHP
Powder: Silhouette (also order Power Pistol and Sport Pistol but order is delayed and probably won't get them for a while)
Primers: CCI 500, Federal, Federal premium gold
Casings: Mostly once fired Magtech casings, 9mm


I plan on making loads with Silhouette from 5.0 gr to 5.6 gr based on Silhouette's data for 124 SPEER GDHP with 1.105 OAL (I think this is the closest to the MG 124 jhp). When this shelter in place is over, I'll test these loads and hopefully figure out which works best for my gun.

BUT... until I can finally shoot again and test these rounds, I want to crank out 1 thousand rounds of ammo: I have the time, want to get acquainted with the press and reloading process, and am low on ammo.

For the 1k rounds, should I pick right in the middle and load at 5.3 grains? Obviously not ideal to pump out 1k rounds without testing first, but would that be my safest bet in terms of having ammo that my gun will safely/reliably shoot? Am I missing something? I got the powder check die so hopefully I can't mess anything up too badly.

I shoot a CZ Custom Shadow Target. Just paper target shooting at 15 and 25 yards trying to get the smallest group possible. I'm shooting 10 rounds in a 3 inch group from 15 yards on a good mag; large majority stay within 4 inches at 15 yards. No steel shooting (yet).


I also have no sense of how accuracy changes between loads. If I test 5.0, 5.1, 5.2, 5.3, 5.4, 5.5, and 5.6 grains at 25 yards resting on a bench, will I see a noticeable difference in group size? I've seen some youtube videos of ladder testing where I can barely notice a difference. Is the testing across grains mostly about feel/recoil for 9mm? Should I expect improved accuracy when comparing my 5.3gr load vs my factory ammo (Magtech 115gr fmj)? Hoping to see some improvements considering how much I spent on all this gear..

Any help/guidance would be appreciated.

Offline SI VIS PACEM PARRABELLUM

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 5781
Re: Noob wants to load 1k Silhouette MG 124gr JHP
« Reply #1 on: April 11, 2020, 06:11:54 AM »
You are asking for basically a guess on how your gun will perform with a untested load and there's really now way to guess that accurately. You can certainly load at a charge weight in the middle and provided you plunk test and set the bullet at a depth that works in your CZ's barrel they may run reliably but there is no way to know how accurate they will be without testing and loading 1k rounds untested is a risk you take. If they don't perform well then you're stuck pulling alot of bullets. Loading the ladder incrementally is how you taylor a load to our specific gun to find it's most accurate "sweet spot" that's why we do it that way. Different powders,bullets,seating depths and all else factor in and just because the vid you saw didn't show any great changes across the ladder does not mean that is the norm. That just means for the combinations being tested in that situation the spread was nil. After you do some ladder testing with many different components you'll see how spreads can be much different.

Offline nicky

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 973
Re: Noob wants to load 1k Silhouette MG 124gr JHP
« Reply #2 on: April 11, 2020, 07:18:22 AM »
You need to first understand what each station of the of the press does. Making dummy rounds and get comfortable with the press. No powder or primers.

You will also need a bullet puller to brake down those dummy rounds. You have a few weeks to to get familiar with the press and that is what I am suggesting.

I agree with the post above. You don't want to guess about a load and find they don't shoot well. It's no fun if you have to brake down 1000 bullets.

Be sure to read the stickies. A lot of good information there.

The main objective is here is to be safe. Being safe is the most important.

Offline Wobbly

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 12748
  • Loves the smell of VihtaVuori in the morning !
Re: Noob wants to load 1k Silhouette MG 124gr JHP
« Reply #3 on: April 11, 2020, 09:35:19 AM »
I've been wanting to try reloading for a while and finally took the jump. I got a Dillon XL750 delivered this week....

My friend, that's not a "jump"...  you were shot out of a cannon !!  ;D

Bullets: Montana Gold 124gr JHP
Powder: Silhouette (also order Power Pistol and Sport Pistol but order is delayed and probably won't get them for a while)
Primers: CCI 500, Federal, Federal premium gold
Casings: Mostly once fired Magtech casings, 9mm

I plan on making loads with Silhouette from 5.0 gr to 5.6 gr based on Silhouette's data for 124 SPEER GDHP with 1.105 OAL (I think this is the closest to the MG 124 jhp). When this shelter in place is over, I'll test these loads and hopefully figure out which works best for my gun.

We've already done a lot of work for you. If you've gone through our DIRECTORY stickie, then you've seen this...
https://czfirearms.us/index.php?topic=98459.msg759928#msg759928

BUT... until I can finally shoot again and test these rounds, I want to crank out 1 thousand rounds of ammo: I have the time, want to get acquainted with the press and reloading process, and am low on ammo.

Very much Agreed. I'll recommend some additional equipment and some exercises you can do.

Accessories
• Making that many rounds, you're going to want the Dillon Strong Mount option. It places the press more into the center of the bench top, thereby making it far more stable. This in turn will allow you to use less muscle energy, leading to better back and shoulder comfort.

• You're going to need to look inside the cases as they pass, so more light is required. The best light is the "UFO" lights for 650/750 by KMS Squared (they are on Amazon)

• Loading 1000's of cases is also going to generate 1000's of spent primers and smut, and the Dillon solution is simply not up to the task. Order the Spent Primer Chute from UniqueTekHERE  This item uses a hose to route all that trash to a sealed container under your bench where you won't have to breathe that dust and can eventually recycle all the brass for cash.

• As a note: If you ever decide you need bearings or other enhancements, the place to start is a seller on Ebay named "Snowshooze" and he makes the very best working bits. He's got a 650 "kit", and may have a 750 "kit" by now.

Exercises
• The powder measure is the place to start. Install the Small Powder Bar. Dillon PMs are typically stiff for the initial several thousand drops so the first thing to do is squirt powdered graphite down into the hopper. You can get that in the Lock Section of any hardware store, or HERE. Then you'll want to add rubber bands to assist the slide in its return. I use a light weight spring (see photo) off the early Dillons, but rubber bands work just fine. You'll also want to use a Sharpie Marker to denote the directions. And you can get the knobs from Ebay vendors, typically 2 for $5.



• Once all that is complete you can take one of your used cases (with old primer in place), fill the hopper at least 1/2 full with powder, and start running powder through the PM. This loosens up the PM, distributes the graphite (which is also coming off the powder), and will help you adjust the belling while you play.

• If you'll weigh each of the powder drops after a fresh fill, you'll see that the weight varies wildly for the first 6-9 drops. Since reloaders want consistent weights, you learn your first rule: Never use the first ten drops. Back into the hopper they go. Keep doing powder drops and exercising the PM. You want just enough case belling so that the bullet will just barely balance on top of the case. And you want to practice dialing in on your desired powder weight.

• Since all PMs have small variations in the powder weight, the best way to learn to adjust any PM is by the averaging method. If your notes tell you that you want 5.3gr of a certain powder, then drop ten (10) and see how close you come to 53.0gr. That way some my be at 5.29gr and some will come out at 5.31gr, but the overall average will land smack dab on 5.30gr. Practice that.



• When you finish for the day, the very best practice is to pour the powder back into the can. This in itself leads to 2 ideas... first you're going to need a funnel. Second, you're going to want to pour it back into the correct can. Therefore: Rule #2: Only keep one, single can of powder on your bench top. All the others are across the room or under the bench. You cannot mix powders.

For the 1K rounds, should I pick right in the middle and load at 5.3 grains? Obviously not ideal to pump out 1K rounds without testing first, but would that be my safest bet in terms of having ammo that my gun will safely/reliably shoot? Am I missing something? I got the powder check die so hopefully I can't mess anything up too badly.

First of all, you're going to place your Seating Die in position #4, which allows easy visibility into the case. With your UFO lighting this will be a reality. You'll either need to watch the Powder Check (which can lie to you if it's not properly set) or you'll need to watch the physical powder. One or the other. I think it's easier to watch the powder myself, right before you place the bullet.



I shoot a CZ Custom Shadow Target. Just paper target shooting at 15 and 25 yards trying to get the smallest group possible. I'm shooting 10 rounds in a 3 inch group from 15 yards on a good mag; large majority stay within 4 inches at 15 yards. No steel shooting (yet).

I use the smallish 4x6 individual TQ-2 NRA target. HERE This has a 2.3" bull. I always shoot this at 30 feet from a sand bag or other supported position so I can compare targets from 10 years ago. You'll want to standardize your testing on some similar target and distance.



I also have no sense of how accuracy changes between loads. If I test 5.0, 5.1, 5.2, 5.3, 5.4, 5.5, and 5.6 grains at 25 yards resting on a bench, will I see a noticeable difference in group size? I've seen some youtube videos of ladder testing where I can barely notice a difference. Is the testing across grains mostly about feel/recoil for 9mm? Should I expect improved accuracy when comparing my 5.3gr load vs my factory ammo (Magtech 115gr fmj)? Hoping to see some improvements considering how much I spent on all this gear..

You want a good target so that you can shoot each load at a new target. The target with the tightest group will be your best load in your gun with your powder and your bullet. My gun will be completely different. Performance is simply on an individual gun basis. My results may help you get from 100 loads down 4 or 5, but you must still test those 4 or 5 in your gun. There's simply no way around it. I highly suggest 8-10 cartridges per test group, using ALL the same bullet, brass and primers. That way there's only one variable: the amount of powder.

Any help/guidance would be appreciated.

We'll gladly answer any questions you have equipment, accessories, adjustments or just the jolts and bumps of getting started.

PS:
• Best powder scale: the Ohaus 505 series. Sold as he Dillon Eliminator or on Amazon HERE

• Dillon doesn't really have a good answer for seating your bullet (same as the XTP and Precision Delta JHP), so I make a slip-in seating anvil that lots of people use. They give you a precision seating and centering, which is important for competition. Contact me by PM if you want one.

« Last Edit: April 11, 2020, 10:47:35 AM by Wobbly »
In God we trust; On 'Starting Load' we rely.

Offline Earl Keese

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 5186
Re: Noob wants to load 1k Silhouette MG 124gr JHP
« Reply #4 on: April 11, 2020, 09:35:55 AM »
I agree with Nicky's and SVPP's replies. The learning curve is steep starting out with a progressive, kind of like learning to dive from the 27m platform.
 The last thing you need to do is "crank out" ammo. I know it's just an expression, but cranking out ammo is the opposite of what is needed for a new reloader. Not only do you need to learn what each station does, you need to learn how each station "feels" independent of the others. You need to develop a consistent stroke with the lever, learn to watch cases for correct charge, get a feel for primer seating depth, the list goes on.
 After practicing with dummy rounds, start with small batches, measure, record, then test and repeat. At this point, you don't know what you don't know. 1000 round runs are a ways down the road if you approach this safely.
 Reloading is all about process. It's much better to methodically develop the correct process now, instead of bad habits that have to be corrected later because you didn't take time to understand on the front end. No need to rush to stockpile loaded ammo when you have the components on hand.

Offline Wobbly

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 12748
  • Loves the smell of VihtaVuori in the morning !
Re: Noob wants to load 1k Silhouette MG 124gr JHP
« Reply #5 on: April 11, 2020, 10:13:15 AM »
The learning curve is steep starting out with a progressive, kind of like learning to dive from the 27m platform.


"Steep", as in not knowing how to swim.... and then going to the 27m platform !!  :o  O0
In God we trust; On 'Starting Load' we rely.

Offline joejoe05

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 31
Re: Noob wants to load 1k Silhouette MG 124gr JHP
« Reply #6 on: April 12, 2020, 11:37:18 PM »
I've been reading through the stickies and can't believe the quality of work there. Super impressed!

I'll definitely do the plunk test and make tons of dummy rounds before I make any live ones. Really appreciate everyone advice here.  I'm just as excited to learn the intricacies of the press as I am to shoot my own ammo, and plan on taking my time to learn it well. I'll start small before cranking them out :)

I ordered a bullet puller, a spent primer chute, and ufo lights thank to you guys..  :o






Offline Wobbly

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 12748
  • Loves the smell of VihtaVuori in the morning !
Re: Noob wants to load 1k Silhouette MG 124gr JHP
« Reply #7 on: April 13, 2020, 08:50:02 AM »
• There are lots and lots of great accessory products available for the 650/750. Some make life easier, some really improve the quality of the ammo. If you see an issue, just ask. We've bought most of them and can advise.

• You'll have hundreds of question. Don't hesitate to ask. We all asked the same questions when we started.

• One of your first questions is going to be: "I set my OAL too long"... Yes, it's OK to send auto pistol cartridges back through. and reduce the OAL. However, Taper Crimp may/may not work that same way. Due to "spring back", brass likes to move at least ~0.003" per die operation. So if your TC is at 0.378" and you're trying to set 0.377" it may not work. You may need to start with a cartridge that's out at 0.380". The best settings are done in production where you can tweak on dozens of cartridges. Once TC is set, it's good for a year. OAL will change with every new load.

• One of the bits I 'discovered' (really simply borrowed and re-applied) is to put an o-ring under the lock nut for the Dillon Seating Die. It makes adjustment easier and keeps the adjustment from changing once set.



All the best.


PS. Since we've told you a bunch, maybe you can answer something for us. A question that has raged in my mind for 40 or 50 years now. Maybe you can help: Did in fact, JoeJoe really leave his home in Tucson Arizona ?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXjsM1zcH1g

These are the things that keep me awake all night.  ;D
« Last Edit: April 13, 2020, 09:07:12 AM by Wobbly »
In God we trust; On 'Starting Load' we rely.

Offline newageroman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1252
  • Press or cry like the rest...
    • The Brass Bucket - Brass Trading Website
Re: Noob wants to load 1k Silhouette MG 124gr JHP
« Reply #8 on: April 13, 2020, 09:14:17 AM »
I've been reading through the stickies and can't believe the quality of work there. Super impressed!

I'll definitely do the plunk test and make tons of dummy rounds before I make any live ones. Really appreciate everyone advice here.  I'm just as excited to learn the intricacies of the press as I am to shoot my own ammo, and plan on taking my time to learn it well. I'll start small before cranking them out :)

I ordered a bullet puller, a spent primer chute, and ufo lights thank to you guys..  :o

Throw that bullet puller in the trash if its a kinetic hammer type one. I had one pop a primer with a live 30-06 round.  The primer went sailing across the room. I still have an arm. I do NOT have a kinetic bullet puller anymore. I have lots of "BAD BULLETS" to throw into the next fire as opposed to pulling them.

Even working a few years on the 650 I wont morek more tha ~100 rounds before testing the. cause pulling them sucks.

When you make the dummy rounds leave the primers out of them so they are easily identified.

Welcome to the club!

You certianly jumped in with the 750!


P.S. I'm in the south and going to shoot test rounds today, then pump out piles of 9mm for the CZ on the 650 - sorry couldn't resist... :)

Ricky Ace Range Review: https://rumble.com/c/c-1388111
75B-BullShadow SAO (Limited Optics)
SP-01-SAO-comped (OpenMajor)
97E SAO, 97B, SAR copies
..others..

Offline joejoe05

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 31
Re: Noob wants to load 1k Silhouette MG 124gr JHP
« Reply #9 on: April 14, 2020, 01:22:58 AM »
Quote
PS. Since we've told you a bunch, maybe you can answer something for us. A question that has raged in my mind for 40 or 50 years now. Maybe you can help: Did in fact, JoeJoe really leave his home in Tucson Arizona ?

LOL. Well according to the song, he left his home in Tucson, Arizona for some California grass  ;D


Quote
Throw that bullet puller in the trash if its a kinetic hammer type one. I had one pop a primer with a live 30-06 round.  The primer went sailing across the room. I still have an arm. I do NOT have a kinetic bullet puller anymore. I have lots of "BAD BULLETS" to throw into the next fire as opposed to pulling them.

Almost did, but decided to go with the RCBS bullet puller and collet.


Appreciate the help guys! I'm waiting for my workbench to come so I can finally install the press, but it keeps getting delayed... It's killing me. I've been sorting brass by headstamp and tumbling them just to feel like i'm doing something..

Offline Wobbly

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 12748
  • Loves the smell of VihtaVuori in the morning !
Re: Noob wants to load 1k Silhouette MG 124gr JHP
« Reply #10 on: April 14, 2020, 03:32:43 PM »
Well according to the song, he left his home in Tucson, Arizona for some California grass  ;D


Well, I always considered it poetic license, since everyone knows the only reason to leave Tucson is to head over to the Dillon plant in Phoenix.   ;D


I've been sorting brass by headstamp and tumbling them just to feel like I'm doing something..


We are a full-service reloading forum.



Joejoe, you are doing something. And it's not just any old social distancing make-work keep busy task, it's something very important. And in weeks to follow you'll be very glad you had the courage, conviction and forethought to take this immensely pro-active step.

You are a man of action ! And, you're going to make a wonderful reloader, because by golly you are good enough, and smart enough.


[To continue to receive more reloading affirmation, please insert another coin.]
 ;D
In God we trust; On 'Starting Load' we rely.