The first time I called CZ, the gunsmith I first spoke to also said that the good version was brown and the bad was silver. This is a little deceiving though, because it is not bright shiny silver, but dull and could be perceived as brownish looking.
I could not tell just by looking at it with the bolt in the gun, so I disassembled it and removed the bolt so I could get a real good look. I then called CZ back and spoke to a different gunsmith (the head one I believe) and he informed me of the difference is in the taper (which is easier to discern) as I posted above. He also said if I called back three times, I would get three different instructions of how to tell the good from the bad. The taper difference is to me, the easiest to spot. Color is really hard to tell the difference without a reference point.
If I could figure out how to post a picture here I have one that shows both side by side so you can see the difference of the one I removed from my 712 and the one CZ sent me as the replacement.
If anyone would like the picture, reply just to me or post an email address and I will send it.