I also have one of these Hogue holsters, and I like it a lot. I use the belt base and it holds the pistol fairly closed. The included paddle option causes the pistol to be set "out" farther, which is okay for carry in the open, but not for any concealed carry. The belt base will work for concealed carry with winter/heavy clothing, but not for summer or lighter wear clothing. But, the form, fit, and function of the holster is perfect and the thumb release and draw is fast and excellent.