The lug on the trigger guard takes the impact of the slide. It usually has no problems because it is backed up by the frame behind it. But, if the frame surface is not smooth it can stress the lug tremendosly.
Check the frame surface, that is behind the lug when it is closed. See if it has a burr, or if there is anything stuck to it. If so, it could break your new trigger guard.
If there is something stuck there, it might not be hard to get it off.
HTH