This afternoon I made a trip to Lowe's and Home Depot hoping they might have a 1/2"-28 bolt in their specialty sections. The largest 28 thread count bolt they had was 1/4". I checked the drill/tap supplies and as expected, no dice. They only had coarse threads in 1/2" size. However, on the drive home it suddenly hit me that my suppressor ready P-09 has 1/2-28 threads!!!
The CZ thread protector screwed freely on to the AR barrel, while the flash suppressor hung up in the same spot. Ballistic Advantage - 1, Yankee Hill Machine - 0.
So, I can order a 1/2"-28 tap, take it to a gunsmith, or send it back to Primary Arms as a defect/out-of-tolerance. Given that all of my options involve more time and money, I am leaning toward the last one. Honestly, while I'm happy to have bought the YHM muzzle device on sale for $24, my experience hasn't met my expectations after reading all of the 5-star reviews. I am sure I just got a dud, but the fit and finish are also on par with what I paid.