It looks good, but it's always hard to judge a finish by a photograph. There are just so many points on the matte vs shiny axis that it's the kind of thing you really need to see up close, turning in your hands to see it under various angles against the light. Is that satin nickel? Generally speaking, that's my favorite handgun finish, but again - there are subtle differences within those finishes, and I'd really need to see it up close to judge.
Therefore, I think the logical solution is to just send me that gun for observation and objective analysis (the two "obs").
For science.