When you polish it don't go any finer than 320 grit, it needs to be rough enough to get a good even blue. It will be nice if you take your time. It may take two to three weeks depending how dark you want it but it will be nice. Boil in water, apply solution, allow it to rust for 24 hours until it is a nice orange, boil in water until it is a black oxide, card off the gun, rinse & repeat. It is a long labor intensive job but I did a S&W model 19 and it turned out amazing.