I'm all about Purdy!!!
While I don't consider the Broomhandle or Luger to be good looking, I do put them in the "Exceptionally Cool" category. Even the 1861 Navy Colt goes there in a homely sort of way.
You have to admit that cowboy guns set the standard for handgun beauty. So my first choice would have to be the Colt Peacemaker & variables.
The picture does the Ruger Montado (bottom) absolutely no justice. It really is a beautiful pistol.
Next, I have to go with a fighting pistol & nothing screams fighting like a good ol' 1911. I need to add a Dan Wesson Bobtail, something fierce.
Don't get me wrong, I think my matte stainless 75B is nice but the P01 just looks better.